MDF · 01 KL Packaging

The Field Guide Comparison

Cratejoy vs Subbly: What Changes for Your Fulfillment

A fulfillment-side comparison of Cratejoy and Subbly for subscription box operators. How each platform batches orders, exports them, connects to shipping software, and hands off to a 3PL, from each platform's own docs.

In this pieceFrom this piece
  1. How each platform tells you what to ship
  2. Getting orders to your packer
  3. Tracking numbers back to the platform

Excerpt. The full list is in the piece below.

Leaves: In this piece

Most Cratejoy vs Subbly comparisons are about storefronts, checkout, and marketing. This one is about the part that happens after the charge goes through: how each platform tells you what to ship, how the orders get to whoever packs them, and how tracking gets back to the customer.

Everything below comes from each platform’s own pricing pages and help docs, accessed October 22, 2026. Some of the help articles are a few years old, and both platforms change, so check the linked page before you build a process on it. Neither platform reviewed or sponsored this page.

Subbly or Cratejoy: which is better for fulfillment?

Choose Cratejoy if its marketplace audience matters to you and you want shipments grouped into monthly batches with a detailed shipments export. Choose Subbly if you want a lower percentage fee and more ways to push orders out automatically, through ShipStation, Pirate Ship, Zapier, webhooks, or its Orders API. Either one can feed a 3PL.

Fees and plans, as listed on each pricing page:

ItemCratejoySubbly
Entry planMarketplace only: $24.99/mo paid yearly or $29 monthlySubbly: $51/mo paid yearly or $69 monthly
Website plansEssentials $59/mo yearly or $79 monthly; Advanced $159/mo yearly or $199 monthlyMax $111/mo yearly or $149 monthly; Subbly X from $499/mo
Platform transaction fee1.25% + $0.101% + 12 cents (1.25% on other gateways)
Marketplace referral fee15% on marketplace orders and renewalsNo marketplace
Payment processor feesExtraExtra

Sources: Cratejoy pricing, Subbly pricing.

How each platform tells you what to ship

Cratejoy: batches and a cutoff window

Cratejoy groups subscription shipments into batches. On the Shipments page, the “What to Ship” filter shows Previous Batch, Current Batch, and Next Batch. The current batch is meant to ship on or just after your target ship date, and the list is finalized on the first day of your cutoff window. Cratejoy recommends shipping right after the cutoff window begins (Cratejoy: Shipping schedules).

The “Current Batch” filter shows every shipment in the batch regardless of status, so add a status filter of “Unshipped” to see what is left (same article). One-time product orders show up in a separate view and should ship as they come in.

Subbly: shipping dates per order

Subbly works per order. Each order has a shipping date, and when pending orders reach that date they are pulled into ShipStation automatically if you use that integration (Subbly: How does the ShipStation integration work?). You can change an order’s shipping date by hand from the customer’s order slip, though Subbly does not recommend it because it adds manual work (Subbly: Handling orders).

For a 3PL, the difference is how you hand off a pack run. With Cratejoy, the natural unit is the batch. With Subbly, it is the set of orders due on or before a date.

Getting orders to your packer

Cratejoy exports

Cratejoy’s shipments export comes in CSV (all shipments, current filter, or selected) and as packing slips. You can filter by status, batch, product, term, subscription cycle, gifting, and add-ons, and sort by rebill date (Cratejoy: Shipments export).

The export columns are useful for anyone packing variable boxes. They include:

  • target_ship_date, which decides the batch a shipment belongs to
  • first_shipment and shipment_number, so you can put a welcome insert in a customer’s first box
  • subscription_cycle_count and subscription_term, for sequential boxes and for renewal inserts near the end of a prepay
  • is_gift and gift_message
  • variant columns for selections such as size or color

Cratejoy’s own FAQ in that article walks through those insert scenarios. Cratejoy also says it can print shipping labels on your own thermal printer and offers an API for sending data to other systems (Cratejoy: Features).

Subbly exports

Subbly’s Orders page has a CSV export, filters, and a column picker (Subbly: Handling orders). For shipping services it does not integrate with natively, Subbly’s documented process is: export the orders CSV, import it into the other service, print labels there, then mark the orders shipped in Subbly, one at a time or in bulk (Subbly: How to use other shipping services with Subbly).

Subbly also documents three automated routes for sending order data out: Zapier (with shipping apps such as Easyship, Shippo, and ShipEngine), webhooks fired by an “Order created” automation, and its Orders API for custom fulfillment setups (same article).

ShipStation and Pirate Ship

Both platforms connect natively to ShipStation and Pirate Ship (Cratejoy: Features; Subbly: How to use other shipping services). ShipStation matters if you outsource packing. Subbly notes that ShipStation “can also help bridge the gap” between your store and a 3PL (Subbly: ShipStation integration).

Quirks worth knowing before you hand ShipStation to a packer:

Cratejoy (ShipStation FAQ; Using the ShipStation app):

  • Shipments sync on the shipment’s order date and appear in ShipStation as orders.
  • With Auto Mark as Shipped on, tracking flows back and shipments are marked shipped.
  • A cancelled shipment updates in ShipStation. An uncancelled one does not move back to Awaiting Shipment; someone has to move it by hand.
  • Cratejoy recommends exporting Unshipped + Current Batch and checking it against ShipStation before each run.
  • ShipStation’s timezone must be set to GMT.
  • Test orders do not sync.

Subbly (ShipStation integration):

  • Printing labels in ShipStation marks the orders shipped in Subbly and emails the customer, with tracking if available.
  • If some products have inventory SKUs and others do not, products without a SKU are left off the ShipStation order. Use SKUs on all products or none.
  • Coupons do not appear on the ShipStation order, though the order total is correct.
  • Edits to shipping items after an order is marked shipped do not update in ShipStation.

Watch the SKU rule. A missing line item on a pick list means a missing item in a box.

Tracking numbers back to the platform

If your packer prints labels outside the platform, tracking still has to get back to the customer.

  • Cratejoy: upload a CSV of shipment ID and tracking number pairs on the Shipments page, with an option to mark those shipments shipped at the same time (Cratejoy: Upload tracking numbers). Bulk mark-as-shipped works on a filter or a selection (Cratejoy: Bulk marking as shipped).
  • Subbly: orders mark shipped automatically when labels print through its ShipStation or Pirate Ship integration. Otherwise you mark them shipped manually, singly or in bulk, which sends the Order Shipped email if it is turned on (Subbly: Handling orders).

What to ask a subscription box 3PL, whichever platform you use

  1. How will you receive our orders: ShipStation, a CSV we send, or something else? Who pulls them, and when?
  2. How do you handle box variants, first-box inserts, and gift messages from our export?
  3. How does tracking get back to our platform, and who marks orders shipped?
  4. What happens to orders that come in after the pack run starts?
  5. How do you count and report inventory between pack runs?

Get the answers in writing before your first pack date. For what a box costs to pack and ship, see our subscription box fulfillment service and starting rates.

How do you open a subscription box business?

Start with the box, not the platform. Pick a niche, price one box with real product, packaging, and postage costs, and confirm you can source the contents every month. Then choose a platform, set your billing and ship dates, launch to a small list, and decide who packs: you, or a fulfillment partner once volume makes it worth it.

The platform choice affects fees and fulfillment workflow, which is what this page covers. Both platforms offer a 14-day free trial per their own sites (Cratejoy: Features; Subbly pricing), so you can test the export and shipping workflow with a test order before you commit. Note that Cratejoy test orders do not sync to ShipStation (Cratejoy: ShipStation FAQ).

We have not found a neutral, current count of subscription box businesses that we trust. What the platforms themselves say: Subbly reports 20,000+ merchants over 11+ years, and Cratejoy’s marketplace page reports 1,500+ merchants and 4 million monthly views. Those are the platforms’ own numbers, not independent research (Subbly pricing; Cratejoy pricing).

Do platform fees eat a subscription box margin?

They can be, but the margin is thin enough that small fees matter. On a $40 box, Cratejoy’s 1.25% + $0.10 platform fee is $0.60, and a marketplace order adds a 15% referral fee, another $6.00. Subbly’s 1% + 12 cents is $0.52. Payment processing comes on top of either, before product, packaging, packing labor, and postage.

Those fee figures are calculated from each platform’s published pricing (Cratejoy pricing; Subbly pricing). Run the same math on your own box price, and add your churn: a box that pays back only after several months needs subscribers who stay that long. The full cost breakdown is in subscription box fulfillment cost.

Talk to us about your pack run

We pack and ship subscription boxes in Medford, Oregon. Tell us which platform you use, your box count, and your ship date, and we will tell you how we would take your orders and what it would cost. Call (541) 531-8797 or send the details.

Sources for platform fees

Accessed October 22, 2026. Help-article dates are the “modified” dates shown on each page where available.

Last updated: October 22, 2026

Trevor Lee

Owner, KL Packaging · Medford, Oregon

Trevor owns KL Packaging in Medford, Oregon. Questions about anything in this piece go straight to him.

Trevor’s profile Ask a question

Next step

Planning fulfillment for your subscription box? Ask Trevor.

A written quote from the owner, not a sales rep. We aim to reply within one business day. If we are not the right shop for what you need, Trevor will tell you that too.

Your paper trail

  1. 01In this piece
  2. 02Written quote
  3. 03Reading list

What comes back

  • A reply from Trevor about fulfillment for your box
  • A written quote if you want one
  • Calendar link or a one-page reply
Reviewed by
Trevor Lee, owner
Reply
We aim to reply within one business day.
How you reach us
Direct email + cell